Makeup, Product Reviews, Tips & Tricks

Top 10 Drugstore Mascaras for Unbelievable Lashes

Makeup can be expensive, that’s why tracking down the best drugstore products is a must for any beauty lover! To save you the trouble, we’ve rounded up the most-loved drugstore mascaras on Influensters spoke out about their favorites in the Reviewers’ Choice Awards, make sure to check out all the winners for best in beauty!

These mascaras will lengthen, strengthen and volumize lashes without breaking the bank.  If you’re looking to try a new mascara, we have the perfect list for you: mascaras will lengthen, strengthen and volumize lashes without breaking the bank.  If you’re looking to try a new mascara, we have the perfect list for you:


Maybelline Great Lash Mascara


This mascara has been “America’s favorite” for over 40 years. Great Lash’s formula conditions nails as it thickens to make full, glamorous and clump-free lashes.

Price: $5.49

What Influensters Say: With over 3,500 reviews there’s no denying this is a popular product! Influensters have given it a 4-star rating and voted it #1 in the Influenster Reviewers’ Choice Awards! claiming that it lengthens lashes without making them clump. One reviewer trusts it’s quality so much she wore it on her wedding day!


L’Oréal Telescopic Original Mascara


This mascara uses a unique flat-sided brush to lengthen lashes up to 60% and a comb to separate lashes with precision!

Price: $9.49

What Influensters Say: This is drugstore mascara is impressively ranked 27th on our site. To top it off, Influensters have given it a 4.5-star ranking claiming that its lengthening, clump-free application makes it irresistible!


NYX Cosmetics Lush Lashes Mascara



This mascara will give your lashes an XXL boost thanks to its oversized brush that grabs lashes for even coverage from root to tip!

Price: $6.99

What Influensters Say: Influensters say this mascara “works like a dream” and have given it a 4.5-star rating! Lashes stayed incredibly curled thanks to the thickening and volumizes lashes to epic proportions.


COVERGIRL Plumpify Problast Mascara


This extremely volumizing mascara uses a curved brush to amplify you lashes up to 50x without clumping!

Price: $10.49

What Influensters Say: With a 4-star rating, Influensters can’t get enough of this mascara! They love how the brush reaches even hard to reach lashes to ensure even coverage. While this is a volumizing mascara, reviewers claim that it also adds dramatic length for a beautiful, all-around look!


Almay One Coat Get Up & Grow Mascara


The gentle formula of this Almay mascara strengthen and lengthen you lashes as you use it, giving you long-wear mascara that benefits you in the long run!

Price: $6.49

What Influensters Say: This 4.5-star mascara will give you great lashes without irritating even the most sensitive eyes. Influensters love how the lightweight formula amplifies lashes without weighing them down. They also not how it is flake free and gives a more “natural” look!


Jordana Best Volume Extreme Volumizing Mascara


This smear-proof, non-clumping volumizing formula is applied with Jordana’s Mega Brush to create a false lash effect.

Price: $2.99

What Influensters Say: This mascara has over 200 reviews and a 4.5-star rating! Influensters love the lengthening effect and even claim that it gives you “the best lashes ever!”


Rimmel London Scandaleyes Retro Glam Mascara


Scandaleyes uses an hourglass-shaped brush to plump and curve lashes for an “eye-conic” 60’s look!

Price: $5.99

What Influensters Say: Influensters have given this mascara a 3.5-star rating, notably they love how the oversized brush works to curl the lashes too!


Maybelline Full N Soft Mascara


This mascara features an exclusive thickening formula to build up lashes from the inside out. Over time you’ll get softer, plumper and more elastic lashes.

Price: $7.99

What Influensters Say: With a stunning 4.5-star review, Influensters LOVE how this mascara improves overall lash health without flaking off. Influensters also say the formula isn’t to wet and works well for curling lashes!


Revlon Grow Luscious Mascara


This lash enhancing formula complements the natural growth cycle of lashes to create longer, fuller lashes that grow stronger day after day.

Price: $8.49

What Influensters Say: The 670 Influensters who have reviewed this product have given it a 4-star rating. These reviewers consistently love how it fans out lashes for a fuller look.


COVERGIRL The Super Sizer Mascara by LashBlast


This mascara super sizes your lashes with an amazing Lash Styler that gives you 400% more volume!

Price: $7.49

What Influensters Say: This mascara has been given a 4-star ranking by 470 Influensters, they love how volumizing and lengthening it is!


Do you have a favorite drugstore mascara? Share with us in the comments! Find more articles on the Influenster website!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s